Legault defends funding, Liberal breaks ranks
Premier François Legault sees "no problem" with public funding for religious schools.
On Thursday, the leader of the Coalition Avenir Québec (CAQ) had to justify his support for maintaining funding for religious schools, while all his MNAs opposed a motion by the Parti Québécois to put an end to it, in line with the principles of secularism.
Meanwhile, Liberal MNA and leadership candidate Frédéric Beauchemin is breaking ranks and opposing his party's about-face, which is now calling for an end to public funding of religious schools such as the Parti Québécois (PQ) and Québec solidaire.
"What I advocate is that parents have the free choice to send their children to the schools they want," said Frédéric Beauchemin, in an interview with La Presse.
In an unexpected turnaround, the Quebec Liberal Party (QLP) changed its tune on Wednesday and is now opposed to subsidizing these institutions. A change made in the name of gender equality historically defended by the party, as argued by its critic for Education, Marwah Rizqy.
Describing himself as a "team player," Frédéric Beauchemin nevertheless confides that he does not "accommodate" in this boat, a position supported by other members of the Liberal caucus and several activists, according to our information.
Instead, he denounces a regrettable "amalgam" between the controversy at Bedford School, which rebounded again in the National Assembly on Thursday, and the experience in religious schools. A strengthening of the verifications carried out by the Ministry of Education to ensure compliance with the school curriculum in schools, both private and public, would be rather desirable, he points out.
Liberal MP Frédéric Beauchemin
Let us make sure that the Ministry ensures that the curriculum is respected, but let us not take away the freedom of choice of parents to send their children to private schools that respect the curriculum.
Frédéric Beauchemin, Liberal Member of Parliament
Mr. Beauchemin, candidate for the leadership of the QLP, also insists that party members must be consulted before a position "that dates back to the time of Claude Ryan" is reviewed by the caucus. Under his leadership, the party would allow its MNAs to vote according to their convictions on such important issues, he announced.
The PQ's listOn Thursday, the PQ urged the government to cut subsidies to some 50 establishments "where explicit religious gestures can be found," according to MNA Pascal Bérubé.
Later, the Parti Québécois provided a list, the result of a review of data from the Canada Revenue Agency, of 27 establishments "whose denominational project is directly stated." Among them, there are schools of the Christian faith as well as Jewish and Muslim.
Referring to the case of many well-known colleges including Jean-de-Brébeuf, Notre-Dame and Francois-de-Laval – schools "created by members of the clergy, among others," but which have since become secular – François Legault came to their defence.
"In our opinion, there is no problem in these schools," said the premier, adding that the "important thing" is that the Quebec City pedagogical regime "be followed everywhere, including in private religious schools."
However, some of these schools do not respect the Quebec City curriculum, replied the parliamentary leader of Québec solidaire, Gabriel Nadeau-Dubois, saying that they do not teach the new Quebec Culture and Citizenship (CCQ) course.
This course, which has become compulsory since the beginning of the last school year, replaces the former Ethics and Religious Culture (ECR) course.
ChecksIn recent years, several private and subsidized schools have been singled out because they taught only part of this course or not at all, according to an analysis of the most recent reports of the Commission consultative de l'enseignement privé obtained by La Presse.
This agency of the Ministry of Education is responsible for analyzing the situation of each private educational institution in the province and making recommendations on whether or not to finance them with public funds.
This is the case of the Belz Jewish Community School in Outremont, which saw its funding renewed earlier this year, even though it did not comply with Quebec City's pedagogical regime. The office of Education Minister Bernard Drainville explained that the school, attended by more than 1,000 students, had finally complied with his demands.
The Minister of Education, Bernard Drainville
Bernard Drainville also played it safe by stating that there is no indication, for the moment, that schools that did not teach the ERC course were not also offering the new CCQ course.
"Verifications" in this sense will be carried out, he assured.
"If they don't teach it, they will have to teach it," said Bernard Drainville, without going into the potential consequences for those who do not comply with Quebec's demands. "What happens when you don't respect the law? There are consequences. We'll see which ones. »
"One thing is certain, all schools in Quebec, whether public, subsidized private or non-subsidized private, must teach the content of the educational program," he said.
On Thursday, the leader of the Coalition Avenir Québec (CAQ) had to justify his support for maintaining funding for religious schools, while all his MNAs opposed a motion by the Parti Québécois to put an end to it, in line with the principles of secularism.
Meanwhile, Liberal MNA and leadership candidate Frédéric Beauchemin is breaking ranks and opposing his party's about-face, which is now calling for an end to public funding of religious schools such as the Parti Québécois (PQ) and Québec solidaire.
"What I advocate is that parents have the free choice to send their children to the schools they want," said Frédéric Beauchemin, in an interview with La Presse.
In an unexpected turnaround, the Quebec Liberal Party (QLP) changed its tune on Wednesday and is now opposed to subsidizing these institutions. A change made in the name of gender equality historically defended by the party, as argued by its critic for Education, Marwah Rizqy.
Describing himself as a "team player," Frédéric Beauchemin nevertheless confides that he does not "accommodate" in this boat, a position supported by other members of the Liberal caucus and several activists, according to our information.
Instead, he denounces a regrettable "amalgam" between the controversy at Bedford School, which rebounded again in the National Assembly on Thursday, and the experience in religious schools. A strengthening of the verifications carried out by the Ministry of Education to ensure compliance with the school curriculum in schools, both private and public, would be rather desirable, he points out.
Liberal MP Frédéric Beauchemin
Let us make sure that the Ministry ensures that the curriculum is respected, but let us not take away the freedom of choice of parents to send their children to private schools that respect the curriculum.
Frédéric Beauchemin, Liberal Member of Parliament
Mr. Beauchemin, candidate for the leadership of the QLP, also insists that party members must be consulted before a position "that dates back to the time of Claude Ryan" is reviewed by the caucus. Under his leadership, the party would allow its MNAs to vote according to their convictions on such important issues, he announced.
The PQ's listOn Thursday, the PQ urged the government to cut subsidies to some 50 establishments "where explicit religious gestures can be found," according to MNA Pascal Bérubé.
Later, the Parti Québécois provided a list, the result of a review of data from the Canada Revenue Agency, of 27 establishments "whose denominational project is directly stated." Among them, there are schools of the Christian faith as well as Jewish and Muslim.
Referring to the case of many well-known colleges including Jean-de-Brébeuf, Notre-Dame and Francois-de-Laval – schools "created by members of the clergy, among others," but which have since become secular – François Legault came to their defence.
"In our opinion, there is no problem in these schools," said the premier, adding that the "important thing" is that the Quebec City pedagogical regime "be followed everywhere, including in private religious schools."
However, some of these schools do not respect the Quebec City curriculum, replied the parliamentary leader of Québec solidaire, Gabriel Nadeau-Dubois, saying that they do not teach the new Quebec Culture and Citizenship (CCQ) course.
This course, which has become compulsory since the beginning of the last school year, replaces the former Ethics and Religious Culture (ECR) course.
ChecksIn recent years, several private and subsidized schools have been singled out because they taught only part of this course or not at all, according to an analysis of the most recent reports of the Commission consultative de l'enseignement privé obtained by La Presse.
This agency of the Ministry of Education is responsible for analyzing the situation of each private educational institution in the province and making recommendations on whether or not to finance them with public funds.
This is the case of the Belz Jewish Community School in Outremont, which saw its funding renewed earlier this year, even though it did not comply with Quebec City's pedagogical regime. The office of Education Minister Bernard Drainville explained that the school, attended by more than 1,000 students, had finally complied with his demands.
The Minister of Education, Bernard Drainville
Bernard Drainville also played it safe by stating that there is no indication, for the moment, that schools that did not teach the ERC course were not also offering the new CCQ course.
"Verifications" in this sense will be carried out, he assured.
"If they don't teach it, they will have to teach it," said Bernard Drainville, without going into the potential consequences for those who do not comply with Quebec's demands. "What happens when you don't respect the law? There are consequences. We'll see which ones. »
"One thing is certain, all schools in Quebec, whether public, subsidized private or non-subsidized private, must teach the content of the educational program," he said.